Restaurant · Seafood and Steakhouse

The Colony Seafood and Steakhouse

Irving, New York
Date NightGood for GroupsLocal Favorite
4.2out of 5
Our score
$$$
Review

About

The Colony Seafood and Steakhouse is at 876 Main Road (Routes 5 and 20) in Irving, about 12 miles northeast of Dunkirk. It's about 20 minutes from Fredonia. SUNY Fredonia's restaurant list places it under fine dining. Seafood and steaks are its focus, as the name suggests.

It's rated 4.5 on Google from 511 reviews, 4.5 on Tripadvisor from 59 and 4.0 on Facebook from 166, according to an aggregator, and Menupix shows 4.3 from 42. Reviewers praise the food and attentive staff. It suits date nights, anniversaries and group dinners. It's a local favorite worth the drive up the lake shore.

One listing shows hours of 4 to 9 p.m. on Monday, Wednesday and Thursday, with Tuesday closed, so call 716-934-4826 before going. Reserve for weekends, and ask about weekend hours, since they weren't listed anywhere. It's dinner only, based on the listed hours. The drive along Routes 5 and 20 follows the Lake Erie shore, so allow about 20 minutes from Fredonia.

How we score it 4.2

How we rate places
  • Atmosphere 4/5
  • Experience 4.3/5
  • Quality 4.3/5
  • Service 4.3/5
  • Value 4/5

Our editors' score out of 5, the weighted average of the parts above. Visitor reviews are shown separately and never change it.

Reviews

No reviews yet. Be the first to say what it's like.

Been here? Write a reviewRate it and tell other visitors what it's like.

You can write your review now. When you post it, we'll ask you to log in or sign up, and your review will be waiting when you come back.

Your rating

Nearby