Restaurant · Seafood restaurant and bar (formerly Phish Heads)

Phish Tales

Lake City, Florida
Good for GroupsLocal FavoritePopular
3.9out of 5
Our score
$$
Review

About

Phish Tales is a seafood restaurant at 1445 SW Main Boulevard, Suite 170, in Lake City, about 22 miles southeast of Live Oak. The space used to run as Phish Heads, and some directories still show that name and its old phone number. The current name is what you'll see on the door.

As Phish Heads, the room seated more than 150 people with a full bar and a menu of fresh seafood, hand-cut steaks, sandwiches, wings, salads and burgers. Current listings name fish or shrimp tacos, a fried fish sandwich and peel-and-eat shrimp. One aggregator shows about 4.5 stars from around 283 reviews, and a 2025 review calls the food very good and the staff friendly.

State inspectors last visited on April 14, 2026, with no further action, and there are 34 inspections on record. The size of the dining room makes it a fair choice for groups or families. Because listings mix the two names, call ahead or check a recent source for hours before you go.

How we score it 3.9

How we rate places
  • Atmosphere 3.8/5
  • Experience 4/5
  • Quality 4/5
  • Service 4/5
  • Value 3.9/5

Our editors' score out of 5, the weighted average of the parts above. Visitor reviews are shown separately and never change it.

Reviews

No reviews yet. Be the first to say what it's like.

Been here? Write a reviewRate it and tell other visitors what it's like.

You can write your review now. When you post it, we'll ask you to log in or sign up, and your review will be waiting when you come back.

Your rating

Nearby