Restaurant · Pizza and subs

Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs

Burley, Idaho
BudgetFamily FriendlyGood for Groups
4.0out of 5
Our score
$
Review

About

Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs is a pizza and sub shop at 1061 Overland Avenue in Burley. It's part of a family-run Idaho chain with about a dozen restaurants, so Idahoans may already know the name. The menu covers pizza, subs and salads.

Birdeye rates it 4.4 from 659 reviews, one of the larger review counts in town. Online ordering runs through Slice, which makes it easy to order ahead and pick up a pizza on the way back to your hotel, most of which sit around I-84 Exit 208 on North Overland Avenue. The chain's website is papakelseysonline.com, since we didn't find a Burley-specific site.

It's a budget-friendly choice for families and groups, and subs travel well for a picnic by the Snake River or a drive out to Lake Walcott, about 30 minutes away. Slice shows a 10 AM opening on Mondays, but we couldn't find full weekly hours. Call 208-670-8552 or check the Slice page for that day's hours before you go.

How we score it 4.0

How we rate places
  • Experience 3.9/5
  • Quality 4/5
  • Service 3.8/5
  • Value 4.2/5

Our editors' score out of 5, the weighted average of the parts above. Visitor reviews are shown separately and never change it.

Reviews

No reviews yet. Be the first to say what it's like.

Been here? Write a reviewRate it and tell other visitors what it's like.

You can write your review now. When you post it, we'll ask you to log in or sign up, and your review will be waiting when you come back.

Your rating

Nearby