Restaurant · Pizza and Italian

Pagliai's Pizza

Murray, Kentucky
Family FriendlyGood for GroupsKidsLocal Favorite
4.1out of 5
Our score
$$
Review

About

Pagliai's has been making pizza in Murray since 1979 from 970 Chestnut Street. The Pagliai family brought their Italian recipes to Kentucky, and the name is pronounced Polly-Eyes. Its own site says it has been voted Murray's Favorite Pizza. That's more than 45 years of pizza in Murray.

Dough is made fresh every day and baked in brick ovens at 600 degrees or more. Toppings lean on Wisconsin mozzarella, house-ground beef sirloin and house-made Italian sausage. Build your own pie from 16 fresh toppings, pick a specialty pizza, or go for pasta, wraps, salads or sandwiches, and tourism also lists a pizza buffet.

Families get a lot here, with a free indoor playpark and two game rooms to keep kids busy. Private dining rooms work well for birthdays, teams and other groups. Hours aren't in the sources, so call (270) 753-2975 before you go and ask about buffet times while you're on the line. It sits on Chestnut Street, which is also where Bad Bob's BBQ smokes its meat, so the street is handy for a casual meal.

How we score it 4.1

How we rate places
  • Atmosphere 3.9/5
  • Experience 4.2/5
  • Family Suitability 4.8/5
  • Quality 4/5
  • Service 4/5
  • Uniqueness 3.8/5
  • Value 4.2/5

Our editors' score out of 5, the weighted average of the parts above. Visitor reviews are shown separately and never change it.

Reviews

No reviews yet. Be the first to say what it's like.

Been here? Write a reviewRate it and tell other visitors what it's like.

You can write your review now. When you post it, we'll ask you to log in or sign up, and your review will be waiting when you come back.

Your rating

Nearby