DiCarlo's Original Pizza
About
DiCarlo's Original Pizza is the Steubenville pizza shop at 318 Adams Street that's tied to the origin of Ohio Valley-style pizza. The style puts the cheese on after baking, over a thick, crunchy crust made with high-gluten flour. The sauce uses California tomatoes, the cheese is aged provolone and there are no preservatives.
The family business began as an Italian grocery run by immigrants Michael and Caroline DiCarlo and grew into a bakery. Their son Primo came home from World War II, and the pizza shop opened in 1945 on the 100 block of South Third Street. That store closed in 1977 and a new building went up on Adams Street, and by the late 1950s the family had 24 shops in the Ohio Valley.
A separate DiCarlo's Original Drive-In Pizza operates at 4531 Sunset Boulevard. Hours weren't confirmed for either shop, so call the Adams Street location at 740-282-1081 before you go. Expect cold toppings on a baked crust, which is how the style is served.
How we score it 4.2
How we rate placesOur editors' score out of 5, the weighted average of the parts above. Visitor reviews are shown separately and never change it.
Reviews
No reviews yet. Be the first to say what it's like.
Been here? Write a reviewRate it and tell other visitors what it's like.
You can write your review now. When you post it, we'll ask you to log in or sign up, and your review will be waiting when you come back.